Skip to content
Really Good Sales Funnels

Magic Spoon sales funnel teardown: the build-your-own-box page

The Magic Spoon sales funnel sends a bundle ad to a build-your-own-box page where you pick six products, then choose a subscription that is pre-selected at 24% off. It scored 7.0 out of 10. The ad and page match perfectly. A three-field prize-draw popup on arrival costs it the most.

By The Funnels DeskLast updated 6 min readRubric v1.0

Path tested on a phone, November 19, 2026: Meta ad → bundle builder → plan picker → cart page → Shopify checkout. Ad from Meta Ad Library #990509680726570, running since September 11, 2026.

7.0

Overall score

The best message match in our batch: the ad says build a box, the page is a box builder. The popup on arrival and an unexplained savings number hold it back.

Offer
7/10
Landing page
7/10
Product page
7/10
Cart & checkout
8/10
Follow-up
6/10

Editorial scores from 25 pass/partial/miss checks. How we score

On this page

Where does the Magic Spoon ad send you?

Magic Spoon popup reading Enter to win free cereal, asking for birthday, diet and email address
On arrival: a prize-draw popup with three fields.
Magic Spoon Build Your Own Box page on a phone with 4, 6 and 8 pack options and a review count
After closing it: the box builder, with pack sizes and their discounts.

Before anything else, a popup: "Enter to win FREE CEREAL. Plus, get a gift for your birthday!" It asks for your birthday, your diet from a dropdown, and your email. That is three fields for a chance at a prize, shown to someone who has not yet seen the page.

Close it, and the page is a near-perfect match for the ad. The headline is "Build Your Own Box." Step one is "Choose Your Bundle Size": a 4 pack (save up to 20%), a 6 pack (most popular, up to 24%), or an 8 pack (best value, up to 26%). Under that, 4.6 stars from 31,136 reviews.

A purple bar pinned to the bottom reads "0/6 products selected... add more." It never leaves the screen. It is part progress bar, part cart, and later the buy button. That's why we count the builder as a product-page funnel: the ad opens the thing you buy.

Checks scored at this step

  • Pass

    Message match · Offer

    Ad says "build your custom bundle... save up to 26%"; the page says "Build your own box" and "Save up to 26%."

  • Pass

    Price or discount shown early · Offer

    Pack discounts (20%, 24%, 26%) on the first screen.

  • Partial

    Says what it is · Landing page

    "Build your own box" doesn't say what is in the box until you scroll.

  • Pass

    Primary button on first screen · Landing page

    Pack-size picker plus a pinned "0/6 products selected" bar.

  • Pass

    Proof on first screen · Landing page

    4.6 stars and 31,136 reviews under the pack picker.

  • Pass

    One tap to the buy box · Landing page

    The ad lands on the builder itself.

  • Miss

    Nothing blocks the first screen · Landing page

    "Enter to win free cereal" popup covers the page on arrival.

How does the Magic Spoon bundle builder work?

Grid of Magic Spoon cereals with prices of $9.75 and Add buttons, and the pinned products selected bar
Each flavor has a price and an Add button.
Magic Spoon plan picker with one-time purchase at $53.84 and subscribe and save 24 percent at $43.06 selected
At six of six, the bar opens into the plan picker.

Below the pack sizes is a grid of flavors grouped as cereal, oatmeal, treats, granola and pastries. Each card shows a price, $9.75 for cereal and treats, $7.99 for oatmeal and granola, and an Add button.

We added six products. The pinned bar changed to "6/6 products selected" and opened a plan picker: one-time purchase at $53.84, or Subscribe & Save 24% at $43.06, pre-selected, delivered every 30 days. The button reads "$43.06 | Add to Cart."

That's a well-built choice. The default is the subscription, but the one-time price sits right beside it, so nobody is tricked. What is missing is reassurance. Shipping, returns and how to cancel are not in the picker. The happiness guarantee lives in the FAQ.

Checks scored at this step

  • Partial

    One clear offer · Offer

    Pack discount, subscribe discount and a free bowl set overlap.

  • Partial

    Risk reversal before the cart · Offer

    "100% Happiness Guarantee" is in the FAQ and the cart, not the plan picker.

  • Partial

    Terms are plain · Offer

    Price and frequency are clear; how to cancel is left to the FAQ.

  • Pass

    Price visible · Product page

    Each product card shows its price ($9.75 or $7.99).

  • Pass

    Add-to-cart reachable · Product page

    The pinned bar turns into an Add to Cart button at 6/6.

  • Pass

    Sensible default · Product page

    Subscribe & Save 24% pre-selected, with the one-time price beside it.

  • Partial

    Rating beside the buy box · Product page

    Rating is at the top of the page, not in the plan picker.

  • Miss

    Shipping and returns beside the buy box · Product page

    No shipping or returns line in the plan picker.

What does the Magic Spoon cart show?

Magic Spoon cart page with a free bowl and spoon set and a six-box custom bundle, showing savings of $50.36 and a subtotal of $43.06
The cart lists every flavor and adds a free bowl set.

The cart lists the bundle with all six flavors by name, plus a "Free Bowl & Spoon Set - Subscriber Gift" at $0.00, with $23.00 crossed out. Under the Checkout button: "Try risk-free, 100% happiness guaranteed."

Then the numbers. The bundle shows $43.06 with $56.74 crossed out. The cart says "Savings -$50.36." We could not make those add up from what is on screen. The gap between $56.74 and $43.06 is $13.68, and the bowl set adds $23.00. A savings line that looks bigger than the math invites doubt at the moment you want none.

Checks scored at this step

  • Pass

    Clear confirmation · Cart & checkout

    Cart lists all six products by name.

  • Partial

    Savings and thresholds are plain · Cart & checkout

    "Savings -$50.36" does not reconcile with the prices shown.

  • Pass

    Checkout within two taps · Cart & checkout

    Add to Cart, then Checkout.

  • Partial

    Relevant add-on · Follow-up

    A free bowl set is added; no paid add-on is suggested.

What does the first Magic Spoon checkout screen show?

Magic Spoon Shopify checkout first screen with Shop Pay, PayPal and Google Pay buttons and a total of $44.61
First checkout screen. We stopped here and entered nothing.

Three wallet buttons sit at the top: Shop Pay, PayPal and Google Pay. Below, the familiar note about agreeing to future charges, with a link to the cancellation policy.

The total reads $44.61, against $43.06 in the cart, with the breakdown inside the collapsed order summary. "Email me with news and offers" is ticked by default.

Checks scored at this step

  • Pass

    Express pay up front · Cart & checkout

    Shop Pay, PayPal and Google Pay at the top.

  • Partial

    No surprise total · Cart & checkout

    Cart $43.06; checkout header $44.61, reason folded away.

How does Magic Spoon capture emails?

With the prize-draw popup. It does capture, which counts. But the reward is a chance, not a certainty, and it asks for three fields. Our scoring rubric marks both down because each extra field and each "maybe" gives a visitor another reason to close the box.

The subscription default is the real follow-up engine here. Every buyer who keeps it is a repeat order without another ad. AG1 runs the same idea with a simpler popup in the AG1 funnel teardown.

Checks scored at this step

  • Pass

    Email capture before checkout · Follow-up

    Popup asks for email on arrival.

  • Partial

    Reward is stated and certain · Follow-up

    Reward is a prize draw plus a birthday gift.

  • Miss

    One field · Follow-up

    Three fields: birthday, diet, email.

  • Pass

    Reason to come back · Follow-up

    Subscription is the default plan.

How does the Magic Spoon funnel score on each check?

Each check scores 2 for a pass, 1 for a partial and 0 for a miss. Five checks make a category out of 10, and the overall score is the average of the five categories. The full definitions are on our funnel scoring methodology page.

Offer

7/10
  • PassMessage matchAd says "build your custom bundle... save up to 26%"; the page says "Build your own box" and "Save up to 26%."
  • PassPrice or discount shown earlyPack discounts (20%, 24%, 26%) on the first screen.
  • PartialOne clear offerPack discount, subscribe discount and a free bowl set overlap.
  • PartialRisk reversal before the cart"100% Happiness Guarantee" is in the FAQ and the cart, not the plan picker.
  • PartialTerms are plainPrice and frequency are clear; how to cancel is left to the FAQ.

Landing page

7/10
  • PartialSays what it is"Build your own box" doesn't say what is in the box until you scroll.
  • PassPrimary button on first screenPack-size picker plus a pinned "0/6 products selected" bar.
  • PassProof on first screen4.6 stars and 31,136 reviews under the pack picker.
  • PassOne tap to the buy boxThe ad lands on the builder itself.
  • MissNothing blocks the first screen"Enter to win free cereal" popup covers the page on arrival.

Product page

7/10
  • PassPrice visibleEach product card shows its price ($9.75 or $7.99).
  • PassAdd-to-cart reachableThe pinned bar turns into an Add to Cart button at 6/6.
  • PassSensible defaultSubscribe & Save 24% pre-selected, with the one-time price beside it.
  • PartialRating beside the buy boxRating is at the top of the page, not in the plan picker.
  • MissShipping and returns beside the buy boxNo shipping or returns line in the plan picker.

Cart & checkout

8/10
  • PassClear confirmationCart lists all six products by name.
  • PartialSavings and thresholds are plain"Savings -$50.36" does not reconcile with the prices shown.
  • PassCheckout within two tapsAdd to Cart, then Checkout.
  • PassExpress pay up frontShop Pay, PayPal and Google Pay at the top.
  • PartialNo surprise totalCart $43.06; checkout header $44.61, reason folded away.

Follow-up

6/10
  • PassEmail capture before checkoutPopup asks for email on arrival.
  • PartialReward is stated and certainReward is a prize draw plus a birthday gift.
  • MissOne fieldThree fields: birthday, diet, email.
  • PassReason to come backSubscription is the default plan.
  • PartialRelevant add-onA free bowl set is added; no paid add-on is suggested.

What should you copy from the Magic Spoon funnel?

Steal this

  • If the ad says "build your own," land on the builder, not the homepage.
  • Use a pinned progress bar ("0/6 selected") that becomes the buy button when the box is full.
  • Show the one-time price beside the pre-selected subscription price.

Skip this

  • Don't open with a prize draw that asks for birthday and diet before the visitor sees the product.
  • Don't show a savings total that the visitor can't rebuild from the prices on screen.

How does the Magic Spoon funnel compare with similar funnels?

AG1 also pre-selects a subscription, and its cart labels every saving so the total adds up. Magic Spoon has the better landing page and the weaker cart. Compare both in our subscription funnel examples.

Magic Spoon compared with similar funnels
#FunnelOverallOfferLandingProductCheckoutFollow-up
1CocokindOrganic Chia Face Oil8.8989810
2AG1AG1 Next Gen (90-day subscription)7.8866910
3Magic SpoonCustom Mixed Bundle (6 boxes)7.077786
4BulletproofHigh Protein Iced Coffee, Vanilla6.8610981

Magic Spoon sales funnel FAQ

How does the Magic Spoon build-your-own-box work?

You choose a 4, 6 or 8 pack, add that many products from a grid of flavors, then pick a one-time purchase or a subscription. A pinned bar tracks how many you have picked.

How much does a Magic Spoon 6-box bundle cost?

Our six-product bundle was $53.84 one-time or $43.06 with Subscribe & Save 24%, delivered every 30 days, on November 19, 2026. The total depends on the flavors you choose.

Does Magic Spoon give a free gift to subscribers?

Yes. When we tested, the cart added a free bowl and spoon set, valued at $23, to the subscription order.

What is the biggest weakness in the Magic Spoon funnel?

The arrival popup. It covers the builder with a prize draw that asks for three fields before the visitor has seen anything they came for.

How we tested: we searched the Meta Ad Library for magicspoon.com, opened the ad shown above, and followed it on a phone-sized browser on November 19, 2026. We added one item to the cart and stopped at the first checkout screen without entering any personal or payment details. Stores change often; your visit may differ. Filed under subscription funnels and product page funnels.

AG1 plan selector with a pre-selected 90-day supply

AG1 sales funnel

Meta ad → homepage → product page → cart drawer → Shopify checkout

Score 7.8 · Supplements